The Xbox Series X and PS5 from Microsoft and Sony, respectively, are due to arrive in 2020, almost 7 years after the launch of the Xbox One and the PS4.
- See our The Last of Us Part II review (spoiler-free)
- PS5 DualSense vs. Xbox Series X controller: Which is best?
- See the best PC games you can play while you wait
Sony's PS4 was the clear winner of the last generation, but Microsoft has learned from its early mistakes with the Xbox One and promises not to repeat them this time around.
Let's take a look at how these two consoles stack up based on everything we know so far.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Price and release date
Neither company has given us an official price on its next-gen console yet, but comments from executives along with some leaks offer us clues as to the price range of the Xbox Series X vs. PS5.
While it's far from definitive evidence, pricing for the PS5 has been pegged as starting at $499, according to an Ace Research Institute report (via Twinfinite) and IronManPS5, a leaker with previous credibility. A cost of goods estimate on the PS5 by Bloomberg places the console at around $450, which adds further support for the $499 price point. The wildcard for the PS5 pricing is the Digital Edition that eliminates the Bluray drive and could come in at just $399.
We have less to go on with the Xbox Series X price, but our one source is the head of Xbox, Phil Spencer. In an interview with The Verge, he said, "we will not be out of position on power or price." This is as compared to the Xbox One, which was both $100 more expensive and less powerful than the PS4 at launch. This doesn't give us a definite answer, but it does tell us that there should be little if any price difference between the consoles at launch.
Both Microsoft and Sony have identified "holidays 2020" as the launch timeline for the consoles.
A leaked release date for the PS5 DualSense controller from the same IronManPS5 named above, points to a November 20 launch for both the controller and likely the console as well. This is the week before Thanksgiving in the U.S. and aligns well with previous console launches, the PS4 came out on November 15, 2013 with the Xbox One following it a week later on November 22.
In a recent investor call Microsoft's CFO, Amy Hood, seemingly confirmed a November launch for the Xbox Series X with an affirmative response to a reporter asking if it was still coming during the "November holidays." Our expectation is that both consoles will launch during this same mid-November timeframe.
Winner: Tie. Without the actual pricing for either console, it's impossible to call a winner here. But with identical launch timing and Microsoft suggesting they won't be beaten on price, it's likely this will end in a draw.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Design
We know pretty much everything about the Xbox Series X's design and it's basically a monolith. Microsoft has opted for an extremely minimalist design with the Xbox Series X, a rectangular "tower" that resembles a small desktop PC with an illuminated Xbox logo and a disk slot on the front.
The console is approximately 11.9 inches tall and 6-inches wide and deep. It's not large by any means, but it might be a difficult fit in some entertainment centers.
A single large fan at the top of the Xbox Series X will provide cooling and allow it to be positioned vertically or horizontally and should allow for relatively quiet performance.
Sony finally unveiled its PS5 console months after we first got a glimpse of the Xbox Series X. While it's not for everyone, it's not too much of a stretch to say that it is far more interesting looking than the Series X.
The box is predominately white and features sleek curves. There is a black middle section that slopes like a skateboard ramp. This is where the components are held and there appears to be some ventilation on the edges for cooling. Sony's signature blue lighting accents the edges of the box, giving the console a futuristic look. On the front of the console are USB-A and USB-C ports.
I really like how it looks but not everyone is so enthusiastic about the design. The divisive aesthetic has sparked some polarizing opinions, much like the new DualSense controller, which also features a mostly white color scheme with some black and blue accents.
Winner: Draw. Design is so objective that our preferences don't really matter here. The PS5 is objectively a more interesting looking console but it hasn't proven to be unanimously praised.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Specs
|Xbox Series X||PS5|
|CPU||8x Cores @ 3.8 GHz (3.66 GHz w/ SMT) Custom Zen 2 CPU||8x Cores @ 3.5 GHz (variable frequency)|
|GPU||12 TFLOPS, 52 CUs @ 1.825 GHz Custom RDNA 2 GPU||10.3 TFLOPS, 36 CUs @ 2.33 GHz (variable frequency)|
|Die size||360.45 mm||TBD|
|Memory||16 GB GDDR6 w/ 320mb bus||16 GB GDDR6|
|Memory bandwidth||10GB @ 560 GB/s, 6GB @ 336 GB/s||448 GB/s|
|Internal Storage||1 TB Custom NVME SSD||825 GB Custom NVME SSD|
|I/O Throughput||2.4 GB/s (Raw), 4.8 GB/s (Compressed, with custom hardware decompression block)||5.5 GB/s (Raw), up to 8-9GB/s (Compressed)|
|Expandable storage||1 TB Expansion Card (matches internal storage exactly)||NVMe SSD Slot|
|External storage||USB 3.2 External HDD Support||USB External HDD Support|
|Optical drive||4K UHD Blu-Ray Drive||4K UHD Blu-Ray Drive (Not in Digital Edition)|
|Performance target||4K @ 60 FPS, Up to 120 FPS and 8K||4K @ 60 FPS, Up to 120 FPS and 8K|
Winner: Xbox Series X. Sony put a lot of weight into the speed of its SSD and we'll have to see what that looks like in real-world performance, but at least on paper, the Xbox Series X is the more powerful gaming console.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Performance
In both cases, the proof will come when we can actually see these consoles perform, but for the time being, we have the claims from both companies and they are very close to one another.
The PS5 will be capable of 4K gaming at up to 120 fps and have support for 8K with no specific frame rate target identified yet.
Support for ray tracing is another big addition for the PS5 as this will both deliver considerably more realistic lighting in games as well as some of the 3D audio effects that Sony has boasted about.
Things are fairly similar on the Xbox Series X side with 4K gaming at up 120 fps with 60 fps as the minimum target, although not all games might reach that mark. Support for 8K gaming is also present, but without specific frame rate targets. Ray tracing is also coming to Xbox Series X, although they have made no related audio claims.
Both consoles will also feature custom SSDs that they are promising will deliver dramatically reduced load times versus the previous generation. Sony has been really pushing this message as it could be the winner on this front with dramatically faster (5.5 GB/s vs. 2.4 GB/s) throughput for its SSD.
Winner: Xbox Series X. With both the Xbox Series X and PS5 having virtually identical stated performance it's too hard to make a determination here, but given the better overall specs of the Xbox Series X until we have real-world evidence to the contrary it seems like it will have the edge.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Controller
Neither company is straying far from the basic controller design of the previous generation consoles, and most of the updates look to be internal. If you want a deeper dive we have done a full comparison of the PS5 DualSense vs. the Xbox Series X Controller, but here are the highlights.
The most notable addition to the Xbox Series X controller is a prominent share button in the center of the controller to send content to friends, much like Sony introduced with the PS4's DualShock 4.
Less visible changes are the updated hybrid D-Pad and improved latency to eliminate the delay between a button press and action on the screen. Finally, the new controller is slightly smaller than the Xbox One controller and will be backward compatible with the older console.
On the Sony side, there have also been relatively minimal outward changes to the controller, flashy white colorway notwithstanding. The glowing lightbar has been removed with a glow now simply emanating from below the slightly larger touchpad. Slight changes to the angles of the triggers and the grip are meant to have improved the feel of the controller.
And like the Xbox Series X controller, there are internal changes with the controller providing dramatically improved haptic feedback capable of depicting, for example, the change in the feel of the road in a racing game, and the triggers will offer variable resistance based on the activity being performed in-game.
Winner: PS5. Some of this is going to come down to personal preference certainly, but the DualShock 4 was our favorite controller of the previous generation. Prior to testing the improved haptics and variable resistance triggers, the PS5 DualSense sounds amazing.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Backward compatibility
Microsoft and Sony have both promised backward compatibility with previous generation consoles.
Xbox Series X claims the title for backward compatibility champ with Microsoft promising the next-gen console will not only play all Xbox One games, but it will also include Game Pass games and over 600 Xbox 360 and original Xbox titles. In addition, Microsoft has stated that the older games will "play better than ever before" on the Xbox Series X with double the frame rate (30 to 60 or 60 to 120) on some games along with increased resolution and HDR support.
Beyond games, Xbox One accessories will also be supported by the Xbox Series X.
Sony isn't quite up to the same standard, however, it has confirmed backward compatibility for almost all of the top 100 PS4 games at launch as well as PSVR hardware. A recent patent filing has given some hope that further support for PS1/PS2/PS3 titles will eventually come via a virtual machine emulation.
Winner: Xbox Series X. Sony learned its lesson and is at least offering backward compatibility, but Microsoft has made far more extensive commitments for those that are already invested in Xbox or would like to explore the extensive back catalog of past Xbox consoles.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Games
With similar architecture between the Xbox Series X and the PS5, most PC titles should find their way to both consoles given the presumably reduced developer costs of doing so.
Some of the exclusive highlights for the Xbox Series X include Halo Infinite, Dirt 5, Yakuza: Like a Dragon, Bright Memory: Infinite, and Outriders. The July 23 Xbox Series X games event gave us a look at many of the Xbox exclusives that will be coming through the first year of its release and while not everyone was thrilled, there were definitely some highlights to get fans excited.
In June we finally got a glimpse at some of the games coming to PS5, and we weren't disappointed. Among them are Horizon: Forbidden West (the sequel to Horizon: Zero Dawn), Spider-Man: Mile Morales, Demon's Souls and Sackboy: A Big Adventure (seemingly a LittleBigPlanet spin-off) and Gran Turismo 7.
Those are joined by various indie games, including Stray, Kena: Bridge of Spirits, Little Devil Inside and Bugsnax (from the folks who made Octadad).
Also, some of the major exclusives released this year, such as Last of Us: Part II and Ghosts of Tsushima, will certainly be ported to the new console.
Here is a full breakdown of all the games Sony has revealed so far for the PS5.
Winner: PS5: Spiderman, Horizon: Forbidden West, Demon's Soul -- just naming a few of the AAA titles coming to PS5, not to mention a host of interesting indie games. Until Xbox shows us more Halo, Sony wins this round.
Xbox Series X vs. PS5: Outlook
While there is a lot yet to be decided, the Xbox Series X and PS5 are on level playing field as of now.
The specs for the PS5 don't quite hold up to the Xbox Series X, and until Sony can show real-world results that its hardware is up to the challenge, we have to give the nod to the Xbox Series X.
Sony continues to have the more popular lineup of exclusive titles and no major shakeups or announced exclusives have changed this yet. For nostalgic gamers, the Xbox Series X offers considerably more backward compatibility.
The PS5 also has one of the few clear differentiators between the two consoles in the form of PSVR. Microsoft has made it clear that VR is not part of its console plans.
This is shaping up to be a much closer competition than the Xbox One vs. PS4 at launch, but based on what we know right now, the Xbox Series X has the edge.