Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro: Which premium laptop is for you?

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro
(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

At long last, the Dell XPS 17 is available. So you know what that means? Face-off time! For this episode of laptop face-off, we have the long-awaited Dell XPS 17 and the 16-inch MacBook Pro. Both laptops are serious powerhouses and are workstations hiding in premium laptop chassis. 

In one corner, you have the Dell XPS 17, which is a larger version of its smaller sisters, the Dell XPS 13 and XPS 15. But despite its supposed largeness, it’s actually smaller than a lot of 15-inch laptops currently on the market. Plus, you get a powerful 10th Gen Intel processor, an agile SSD, an Nvidia Max-Q GPU and an impressively bright and vibrant super high-resolution touch screen. 

But not so fast. In the other corner, you have the 16-inch version of the laptop that launched a sea of clones –– the MacBook Pro. The laptop’s iconic design hides an overclockable 9th Gen Intel CPU with AMD graphics. The notebook has its own searingly fast SSD, the company’s always-great Retina display, and seriously long battery life. Each laptop is primed and ready for any productivity/creative/multimedia tasks you set before them, but which system reigns supreme?

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 - Cell 0 Dell XPS 17 MacBook Pro 16-inch
CPU 2.5-GHz Intel Core i5-10300H 2.4-GHz Intel Core i9-9980HK
GPU Nvidia GeForce RTX 2060 Max-Q AMD Radeon Pro 5500M
Storage 1TB M.2 PCIe NVMe SSD 2TB M.2 PCIe NVMeSSD
Display 17-inch, 3840 x 2400 touch screen 16-inch, 3072 x 1920 Retina display
Ports 4 Thunderbolt 3 ports, headset jack, wedge lock slot 4 Thunderbolt 3 ports, headset jack
Battery Life 9:05 10:55
Weight 5.5 pounds 4.3 pounds
Dimensions 14.7 x 9.8 x 0.8 inches14.1 x 9.7 x 0.6 inches

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro pricing and configurations

Like most Dell laptops, the XPS 17 offers several configurations. The laptop’s base model starts at $1,449 and has a 2.5-GHz Intel Core i5-10300H processor with 8GB of RAM, a 256GB M.2 PCIe NVMe SSD, an Intel UHD Graphics GPU and a 17-inch 1920 x 1200 non-touch display. The $2,349 model has a more powerful 2.3-GHz Intel Core i7-10875 CPU, 16GB of RAM and 512GB M.2 PCIe NVMe SSD, as well as an Nvidia GeForce RTX 2060 Max-Q GPU with 6GB of RAM.

Our $3,049 review unit kicks things up a notch with a 2.3-GHz Intel Core i7-10875H CPU, 32GB of RAM, a 1TB M.2 PCIe NVMe SSD, an Intel UHD Graphics GPU, an Nvidia GeForce RTX 2060 Max-Q GPU with 6GB of VRAM and a 17-inch 3840 x 2400 touchscreen. The $3,649 model is the crème de la crème and bumps the RAM and storage up to 64GB and 2TB, respectively.

As for the MacBook Pro, the base model costs $2,399 and has an Intel Core i7 CPU,

16GB of RAM, an AMD Radeon 5300M GPU and a 512GB SSD. The $2,799 model bumps you up to a faster Core i9 CPU, Radeon Pro 5500M graphics and a 1TB SSD.

Our test configuration is a costly $3,899 and ups the SSD to 2TB, the RAM to 32GB and the graphics memory from 4GB to 8GB.

Winner: Dell XPS 17

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro design

Well, we’ve got two silver foxes on our hands. We’re all familiar with Apple’s anodized aluminum frame available in either Space Gray or Silver. The lid is marked with the glossy, iconic half-eaten fruit emblem in the center of the lid. Upon opening the lid, you get more of that gray or silver aluminum, which comprises the majority of the palm rest and deck. 

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

The Force Touch trackpad is positively massive and sits below the black, island-style keyboard that resides in a slight recess. And directly above the keyboard is the Touch Bar, which gives you different menu options depending on the current application. The keyboard is located between a pair of top-firing speakers.

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

Just like the MacBook Pro, the XPS 17 has a platinum silver anodized aluminum along the exterior. A shiny Dell emblem sits in the center of the lid and the sides of the notebook are slightly chamfered for a bit of extra shine. The notebook’s palm rest and keyboard deck are made from black carbon fiber. A large portion of the palm rest is occupied by a gigantic touchpad. The keyboard, which is flanked by a pair of speakers, sits directly above the touchpad. 

Although it’s a 17-inch laptop, the XPS 17 is 48% smaller than most 15-inch notebooks on the market, at 5.5 pounds, 14.7 x 9.8 x 0.8 inches. However, it has met its match in the MacBook Pro, which weighs 4.3 pounds and measures 14.1 x 9.7 x 0.6 inches.

Winner: MacBook Pro

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro security

The XPS 17 has a couple of security measures, including a fingerprint reader embedded in the power button. You also get an IR webcam, which, like the fingerprint scanner, is Windows Hello-compliant. The MacBook Pro has Apple’s Touch ID technology in the power button, however, it lacks the Force ID technology that you find on the iPhone.

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

Winner: Dell XPS 17

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro ports

Both laptops lack legacy ports. Instead, the MacBook Pro and XPS 17 have a pair of Thunderbolt 3 ports on either side. Both systems have a headset jack on the right side, but the XPS 17 has a wedge lock slot on the left side. Recognizing that you might want to connect a mouse or some other peripheral, Dell ships a USB Type-C to USB Type-A dongle.

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

Winner: Dell XPS 17

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro display

Both notebooks have positively beautiful displays. But side-by-side, the XPS 17’s 17-inch, 3840 x 2400 touchscreen has no competition. When I watched the Miss Juneteenth trailer on both notebooks, actress Nicole Beharie’s honey brown skin looked warm and lifelike. However, the rose-pink blouse looked somewhat fluorescent on the XPS 17. It definitely drew your eye, but the hue looked a bit more natural on the MacBook Pro’s 16-inch, 3072 x 1920 display. 

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

If I was choosing a winner based on bezel size, or lack thereof, the Dell and its InfinityEdge design would get the prize. Now removed from all four sides, those thick unsightly bars and thick chin are a thing of the past. Apple has definitely shrunk the bezels on the MacBook Pro, but it’s nowhere near what you get with the Dell. 

When it was time to measure for vividness, the XPS 17’s panel reproduced an impressive 172% of the sRGB color gamut compared to the MacBook Pro’s 114%. The XPS 17’s display was also noticeably brighter, averaging 505 nits while the MacBook Pro reached 429 nits.

Some other advantages the XPS 17 has over the MacBook Pro is Dell Premier Color software, which allows you to tweak the color temperature, gamut and brightness. You also have Dell CinemaColor, which has settings designed to reduce eye strain. Plus, the 10-point touch capacitive panel is made of tough Corning Gorilla Glass 6, so it can withstand a few bumps. 

That’s not to say Apple didn’t give the MacBook Pro any goodies. The notebook has the company’s True Tone technology, which allows the laptop to automatically adjust its color temperature based on the environment. You can also adjust the screen’s refresh rate.

Winner: Dell XPS 17

Dell XPS 17 vs. MacBook Pro audio

When it comes to audio, at least during this face-off, six speakers are better than four as the MacBook Pro plainly proved. The notebook’s top-firing speakers delivered loud audio that I could clearly hear, even when I went downstairs leaving the laptop on the top floor. Although the XPS 17 isn’t as loud as its competitor, it delivered a cleaner, more precise performance. Listening to Rosie Gaines’ “I Can’t Get You Outta My Mind, the MacBook was hands-down louder than the XPS 17. However, the keyboard instrument sounded a tad distorted at full volume. I heard a more restrained presentation on the XPS 17, which allowed me to better hear the drums and lows on the track. 

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

However, when it came to bass-heavy tracks, like Meghan Thee Stallion’s “Captain Hook,” I preferred the more aggressive performance of the MacBook Pro. The bass sounded deeper on the Apple system than on the Dell and it gave Meghan’s salacious rhymes room to shine.

Winner: MacBook Pro

Dell XPS 17 vs MacBook Pro keyboard and touchpad

It’s magic! Magic keyboard that is. After many consumer complaints, Apple got rid of the uncomfortable Butterfly keyboard for the clickier island-style Magic Keyboard. The scissor-switch mechanism below the large keycaps makes for a firm feedback and a satisfying click when a key is pressed. The XPS 17, which has its own Chiclet-style keyboard is comfortable, with deep feedback and clickiness of its own. However, it’s a bit mushy for my tastes. 

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

When I took the 10fastfingers typing test on both systems, I reached 75 words per minute on the MacBook Pro compared to 73 wpm on the XPS 17. Both results were higher than my usual 70-wpm average. 

Each laptop is laden with a massive touchpad that delivers a quick, accurate response when performing gestures, such as pinch-zoom, two-finger scroll and three-finger flick. The XPS 17’s touchpad measures 3.5 x 6 inches, which seems huge. However, the MacBook Pro’s ForcePad is even larger, at 3.9 x 6.3 inches.

Winner: MacBook Pro

Dell XPS 17 vs MacBook Pro performance

This is a true clash of the titans. The XPS 17 is outfitted with a 2.3-GHz Intel Core i7-10875H processor, 32GB of RAM and a 1TB M.2 PCIe SSD while the MacBook is equipped with a 2.4-GHz Intel Core i9-9980HK CPU, 32GB of RAM and a 2TB M.2 PCIe SSD. That means that both systems can handle whatever you can throw at them. Each laptop cut through my real-world test like a knife through butter, running 40 tabs in Google Chrome with a couple of Twitch streams and YouTube videos,

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

But on our synthetic benchmarks, there could only be one. When we ran Geekbench 5.0, our overall performance test, the XPS 17 achieved 7,740. The MacBook Pro was hot on its heels at 7,201. Both notebooks dusted the 4,278 premium laptop average.

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

The MacBook Pro had a bit of revenge on the Handbrake test, taking only 8 minutes to transcode a 4K video to 1080p. This time, the XPS 17 was the one playing catch up with a time of 8:41. Again, both laptops were much faster than the 18:43 category average.

During the File Transfer Test (duplicating 4.97GB of multimedia files), the XPS 17’s SSD clocked a transfer speed of 620.6 megabytes per second. Unfortunately, MacBook’s don’t play nice with this test, forcing us to use the BlackMagic read/write test where the Apple machine hit 1,1017.9 MBps.

Winner: Draw

Dell XPS 17 vs MacBook Pro graphics

Are you interested in photo editing, video editing and maybe a bit of gaming? The XPS 17, with its  Nvidia GeForce RTX 2060 Max-Q GPU with 6GB of VRAM, is the one for you. The notebook also has an integrated Intel UHD Graphics GPU for those moments you aren’t video editing or gaming. The MacBook Pro serves up an AMD Radeon Pro 5500M GPU with 8GB of VRAM. 

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)

Looking to get your game on? The XPS 17 has you covered. On the Shadow of the Tomb Raider benchmark, the XPS 17 hit 48 fps at 1080p, beating the 41-fps category average. At 4K, the frame rate fell to 12 fps, which is a frame shy of the 13-fps category average. 

During the Hitman test, the XPS 17 reached 74 fps at 1080p, cruising past the 70-fps category average. At 4K, the notebook got 36 fps, staving off the 35-fps average. 

Winner: Dell XPS 17

Dell XPS 17 vs MacBook Pro battery life

In spite of their super-high-resolution displays, the MacBook Pro and XPS 17 delivered impressive times on our battery test (continuous web surfing via Wi-Fi over 150 nits of brightness). The MacBook Pro lasted 10 hours and 55 minutes, surpassing the 9 hour and 7-minute average. The XPS 17 was just 2 minutes behind the average at 9:05. 

Winner: MacBook Pro

(Image credit: Laptop Mag)
Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 - Cell 0 Dell XPS 15MacBook Pro
Price (20)1812
Design (10)78
Security (5)53
Ports (5)53
Display (10)108
Audio (10)710
Keyboard and Touchpad (10)710
Performance (10)98
Graphics (10)107
Battery Life (10)710
Total (100)8579

Overall winner

Whether you’re writing reports, creating content or gaming, there’s little the Dell XPS 17 can’t handle. The supersized premium system delivers powerful overall and graphics performance with a swift SSD and a captivating 4K panel, all in an attractive, fairly slim frame. And while our review unit is on the pricier side, it’s still cheaper than the MacBook Pro. Plus, Dell offers a more affordable base model. 

But that’s not to write off the MacBook Pro. It’s a powerhouse in its own right and more often than not is the laptop du jour of creative professionals the world over. You get a lovely display, great performance and nearly 11 hours of battery life. It’s also lighter and smaller than the XPS 17, making it easier to slide in a bag for a commute. But no matter how you slice it, these laptops are at the pinnacle of the premium laptop royalty. 

Sherri L. Smith
Editor in Chief

Sherri L. Smith has been cranking out product reviews for since 2011. In that time, she's reviewed more than her share of laptops, tablets, smartphones and everything in between. The resident gamer and audio junkie, Sherri was previously a managing editor for Black Web 2.0 and contributed to BET.Com and Popgadget.