Apple MacBook (2017) Review

  • MORE

Editors' rating:
The Pros

Faster 7th-generation performance; Still wonderfully thin and light ; Improved keyboard; Good battery life; Runs cool

The Cons

Just single USC-C port; No Thunderbolt 3 support; Low-res 480p webcam

Verdict

The refreshed MacBook offers swifter Kaby Lake performance and a better typing experience while retaining the same long battery life and barely-there design.

Yes, Apple is keeping the MacBook Air around, but the 12-inch MacBook continues to be the company's true flagship ultraportable. It's pricier at $1,299, versus $999 for the Air, but the MacBook is a pound lighter, has a much sharper and more colorful screen and now packs a 7th-generation Core processor and faster SSD for more pep. Apple also refined the keyboard to make it feel cushier. However, some of the same drawbacks remain on this refreshed MacBook, and other super-light Windows laptops -- as well as Apple's similarly priced MacBook Pro -- surpass it in some ways.

article continued below

Design: Still a de-light

Weighing just 2.03 pounds and measuring 0.52 inches thin, the MacBook is still one of the thinnest and lightest laptops around, even if it's not the most attractive system in its class. Apple takes advantage of every square inch, as the keyboard stretches from edge to edge on the deck. We continue to appreciate the solid-feeling aluminum chassis, which is available in Gold, Rose Gold, Space Gray, and Silver.


The competition is definitely catching up to (or surpassing) Apple in the design department, though. Just look at the 13-inch Huawei MateBook X, which is also made of sexy brushed aluminum and is thinner at 0.49 inches, though a bit heavier at 2.3 pounds. It includes a fingerprint reader right in the power button and has narrower bezels.

MORE: The Best Laptops for Every Need

Asus' Zenbook 3 (0.47 inches, 2 pounds) is more of a head-turner than the MacBook in its optional royal blue color and gold accents. The Dell XPS 13 is a heavier and chunkier 2.7 pounds and 0.6 inches, but it has more ports than the MacBook and an SD Card slot.


The most stunning ultraportable remains the HP Spectre, which comes in a bad-ass, ash silver color and is only 0.41 inches thick and weighs 2.45 pounds. But if you want a laptop that feels as sturdy as it is unconsciously portable, the MacBook is a class act.

Ports: Where's Thunderbolt 3?

Unfortunately, the MacBook is still very light on ports. You get only a single USB-C port, and it doesn't support the Thunderbolt 3 standard, which is growing in popularity and can be found on laptops that cost hundreds less. This would allow you to plug the MacBook into a dock and power two displays simultaneously, or attach to a growing number of external graphics amplifiers for when you need more oomph. At this point, no laptop priced $1,000 or more should lack Thunderbolt 3.


You'll definitely want to invest in one or more dongles, such as the USB-C to Lightning Cable ($29) for charging your iPhone, a USB-C to USB Adapter ($19) for plugging in a peripheral with a full-size USB port or a $79 USB-C Digital AV Multiport Adapter, which has HDMI-out for a display, full-size USB and USB-C connections.

Butterfly Keyboard: A better feel

Apple has brought the 2nd-generation butterfly keyboard design from the MacBook Pro line to the MacBook. Thanks to refinements to the dome switches, the result is a layout that feels a lot better than its mere 0.5 mm of travel might suggest. The keys are still flatter than anything you've probably used before, but once you get the hang of it, it's easy to type quickly and accurately.


On the 10FastFingers typing test, I averaged 73 words per minute with 94.82 percent accuracy, both of which are slightly above my usual average.

The 2nd-generation butterfly keyboard feels a lot better than its 0.5 mm of travel suggests.

The 4.4 x 2.7-inch Force Touch trackpad is still pretty roomy given the limited real estate on the deck, and it provided a snappy click sensation along with buttery smooth scrolling. Executing multi-finger gestures, like a three-finger flick up to see open apps, felt effortless.

Display: As bright and colorful as ever

While some ultraportable laptops in this price range make due with full HD screens (1920 x 1080 pixels), the MacBook's display is the sharpest in its class at 2160 x 1440 pixels. I could see every mean wrinkle in the Hulk's neon green face as he hurtled toward Thor in the new Ragnarok trailer.


The MacBook's panel is pretty bright, too, as it puts out 340 nits. That beats the Asus ZenBook 3 and HP Spectre but falls behind the MateBook X (375.6 nits). The MateBook X's screen also produces more of the color gamut than the MacBook at 136 percent to 117 percent. The MacBook's other close competitors are in between 93 and 111 percent.

Where Apple's panel wins out is in its color accuracy. With a Delta-E rating of 0.19 (0 is perfect), the MacBook's display blows away the Spectre and MateBook (both above 6) and is also more accurate than the ZenBook 3's screen (1.8) and XPS 13 (1.3).

Webcam: Still lame

I wish Apple would have upgraded the webcam on the MacBook, as it's still limited to a very low 480p resolution. The color of blue jacket in a selfie I took looked accurate, but the details in my hair and face were fuzzy. If you do a lot of video calls, you're better off buying an external webcam.

Performance: Faster than before but...

It's taken a while, but the MacBook finally has a faster, Kaby Lake chip inside. Because the MacBook sports a fanless design, it comes standard with a 7th-generation 1.2-GHz Core m3 processor that's optimized for efficiency. You also get 8GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD that promises more speed than the last model. (You can upgrade to a Core i5 or Core i7 Y Series CPU. See configuration options.)

Overall, I found the entry-level MacBook quite responsive. I had no problem editing a photo in Pixelmator while streaming Spotify with more than a dozen tabs open in both Safari and Chrome. However, other Windows ultraportables with full-power Core i7 CPUs are faster.

On Geekbench 4, which measures overall performance, the MacBook notched 6,853. That's below the category average of 7,218, and it also trails the HP Spectre (7,888), ZenBook 3 (7,449) and MateBook X (8,419), all of which pack 7th-generation Core i7 chips.

I had no problem editing a photo in Pixelmator while streaming Spotify with more than a dozen tabs open in both Safari and Chrome.

On the other hand, the MacBook offers a faster SSD than other notebooks in its class. It turned in a smoking fast 467 MBps transfer rate, which is more than twice as speedy as the MateBook X and considerably faster than the last MacBook (355 MBps), the XPS 13 (339 MBps) and HP Spectre (299 MBps). However, the ZenBook 3s 508 MBps is tops.

The 12-inch screen on the MacBook wouldn't be my first choice of for working on large spreadsheets, but this machine certainly has the muscle to crunch numbers. On our OpenOffice test, which matches 20,000 names and addresses, the MacBook Air finished in 3 minutes and 2 seconds. The ZenBook 3, HP Spectre, XPS 13 and MateBook X all took longer than 3:30.

The MacBook's Intel HD 615 graphics aren't great for gaming. Even with the racing game Dirt 3 set to a low 1400 x 900 pixels, the system mustered only 23.6 frames per second. The MateBook X hit 71 fps and the Zenbook 3 47 fps, and that was at a higher 1920 x 1080 resolution.

Battery Life: Going the distance

The 12-inch MacBook beats all of the skinniest laptops in one key area: endurance. On the Laptop Mag Battery Test, which involves continuous web surfing over Wi-Fi, the system lasted 9 hours and 29 minutes.

MORE: Laptops with the Longest Battery Life

That runtime beats the ZenBook 3 (7:05) and HP Spectre (6:06) by more than 2 hours, and really means the difference between being able to leave your charger behind or having to take it with you. The MateBook X lasted a very good 8:41 but was behind the MacBook. If you're willing to live with more bulk, the XPS 13 lasts nearly 14 hours on a charge.

The 12-inch MacBook beats all of the skinniest laptops in one key area: endurance.

Heat: Quite cool

For a fanless laptop, the 12-inch MacBook stays remarkably cool. After streaming HD video for 15 minutes, the underside hit 84.5 degrees, well below our 95-degree comfort threshold. The touchpad and the center of the keyboard were even cooler at 78 and 82 degrees, respectively.

Configuration Options: Bring money

Starting at $1,299, the MacBook features a 7th-generation, 1.2-GHz Intel Core m3 processor, 8GB of memory and a 256GB SSD. If you want more power and storage, the $1,599 model includes a Y Series Core i5 chip running at 1.3 GHz and a 512GB SSD.


If you prefer to go the configure-to-order route, it costs $100 to get the Core i5 CPU and $250 to snag a Core i7 chip. But if you're going to spend more on anything, we'd splurge on the $200 it costs to go from 8GB to 16GB of RAM. As our tests have shown, having more RAM can make a significant difference in everyday performance, especially if you like to have a lot of tabs open at once.

Software: Great iOS integration, High Sierra on way

There's nothing really new on the software front with the MacBook, but a public beta of macOS High Sierra is coming in late June, and the final version will hit this fall.

There are some welcome new features in store, such as preventing auto-play videos from playing in Safari and blocking ads from following you around the web to protect your privacy. Other highlights include a new file system that should result in better performance and saving storage, smarter search in Mail and Metal 2 for better graphics performance.

MORE: Best Apple Laptops

In the meantime, there are plenty of things to like about macOS, especially how well iCloud keeps your photos, notes and other files in sync across your MacBook, iPhone or iPad. The ability to quickly AirDrop pictures and videos wirelessly from your iPhone to the MacBook is another plus. And while Mac malware threats are on the rise, MacBooks are generally more secure than Windows 10 machines.

Bottom Line 

If you're in the market for a premium ultraportable, the 12-inch MacBook is a very good option that now offers the performance you deserve in a primary computer. The slightly improved keyboard also helps in terms of productivity, and you get more battery life than other superslim notebooks. We just wish Apple would have added an additional USB-C port so you didn't have to choose between charging your laptop and plugging in a peripheral (without needing an extra accessory). The lack of Thunderbolt 3 support is also a bummer.

Our favorite ultraportable is still the Dell XPS 13 because of its combination of power, ports and even longer endurance. But among Windows machines that are just as light and thin as the MacBook, the Huawei MateBook X is the most tempting choice because it offers more speed along with almost as much battery life. 

Overall, the MacBook is certainly worth the premium, but it's not a slam dunk. That's because Apple now offers a 13-inch MacBook Pro for the same $1,299 price as the MacBook, one that offers an additional USB-C port, Thunderbolt 3 and a faster Core i5 processor. However, that version of the Pro also weighs about a pound more than the 12-inch MacBook and has half as much storage (128GB vs 256GB). So if you prefer macOS, get the MacBook if you want to travel really light, but buy the Pro if you want something more versatile.

Author Bio
Mark Spoonauer
Mark Spoonauer, Editor-in-Chief
Responsible for the editorial vision for Laptopmag.com, Mark Spoonauer has been Editor in Chief of LAPTOP since 2003 and has covered technology for nearly 15 years. Mark speaks at key tech industry events and makes regular media appearances on CNBC, Fox and CNN. Mark was previously reviews editor at Mobile Computing, and his work has appeared in Wired, Popular Science and Inc.
Mark Spoonauer, Editor-in-Chief on
CPU 1.2-GHz Intel Core m3 (7th-gen)
Operating System OS X El Capitan
RAM 8GB
RAM Upgradable to
Hard Drive Size 256GB SSD
Hard Drive Speed
Hard Drive Type SSD
Secondary Hard Drive Size
Secondary Hard Drive Speed
Secondary Hard Drive Type
Display Size 12
Highest Available Resolution
Native Resolution 2304 x 1440
Optical Drive
Optical Drive Speed
Graphics Card Intel HD Graphics 615
Video Memory
Wi-Fi 802.11ac
Wi-Fi Model
Bluetooth Bluetooth 4.0
Mobile Broadband
Touchpad Size 4.4 x 2.7 inches
Ports (excluding USB) USB-C
USB Ports 1
Warranty/Support One-year limited warranty with 90 days free telephone support
Size 11.04 x 7.74 x 0.14-0.52 inches
Weight 2.03 pounds
Company Website www.apple.com
Add a comment
14 comments
  • PauLh Says:

    Do you think upgrading to 16g will really give you noticeable performance improvement on the 2017 MacBook 12" with faster ssd and processor? Looking at getting one, but kind a like speed but want compactness. Thanks

  • MoJoMac Says:

    Is it possible to retrofit this second gen keyboard in my first gen 12"MacBook??? I'm quite happy with my MacBook but the keyboard is the only annoyance I have and would be the only reason for me trade in or trade up my MacBook. Any informed responses from DIYers greatly appreciated!!!

  • KarlB Says:

    If you are not tied to OSX, get a Samsung Notebook 9 (not to be confused with spin or notebook 7). Get the 13 or 15" and save yourself a lot of money. Lightweight, no fan noise, bright sharp screen, 1080p screen, 256gb SSD, 10 hour battery life for the 13", and just the right size even for the 15". Plus you get all the fundamental ports (USB-C, 2 usb, SD slot, HDMI slot) Apple decided to skimp on.

  • Rachel Says:

    The is obviously a cool looking computer. It's lightweight, very fast, and though it takes some getting used to, the keyboard is great. However - don't buy this computer. For almost $2000, you will get a computer that sometimes lasts me 4 hours ... total. As advertised, it should have 10 hours of playback time. I am now on my third brand new computer - because of significant problems. The first computer lasted 6 days before the graphics card went out. The second computer lasted 8 days before showing lines all over the screen. The third computer's battery lasted about 3 hours - writing and receiving emails and working in word and excel. Now my fourth computer has a similar battery problem - that I always seem to look up and it's about to die. If you're looking into buying a computer, DO NOT BUY THIS ONE. Wait until Apple decides to actually address the battery issue - rather than just making a statement saying those computers have battery issues in "development mode."

  • _____ Says:

    id pay 6 for it...................................................

  • GARBAGE Says:

    MacBooks are complete garbage. Horrible battery life and SUPER Laggy when playing simple games like Poker. You have to force quit everything once very often, and SUCH A WASTE OF MONEY.

  • Andrew Says:

    I use the new 2016 MacBook for business, and a 3-year-old 15" Retina MacBook Pro (discreet graphics) for my personal use, which includes high-resolution photography and gaming.

    I bought the new MacBook because the 15" is far more laptop than I need when on the road, and because on the road or at my desk the most demanding task I have for a computer is email through two Exchange accounts (one in Apple Mail and the other in Outlook).

    The MacBook is much slower than the 3-year-old pro in just about everything, but not enough to really interfere. A few seconds here and there, not enough to matter. On the road, however, I no longer dread bringing my laptop or have to make do with just my iPad. In fact, this computer may make the iPad (Air2) irrelevant.

    Overall, I'm quite happy with it. At my desk I have the Apple AV dongle permanently connected to the USB-C charge cable and adapter, HDMI to a 24" monitor and the USB-A port open for whatever I need to connect. On the road, its just a spare USB-C adapter and that's it. No real inconvenience at all, but a whole lot smaller and lighter.

    As for using the new MacBook untethered, its a revelation. The screen is gorgeous, perhaps better (though much smaller) than my 15", and I really like the feel of the keyboard. The speakers are also a real surprise, again perhaps even better than the 15", or at least as good.

    Overall, I'm very happy with this computer, and look at much as I looked at my 12" PowerBook back in 2003 after moving down from the original 15" Titanium PowerBook of a few years earlier.

  • KassyKat Says:

    As someone else posted, the ports are not a problem for everyone, and for many folks, the MacBook is a second computer. I have an iMac at home for heavy computing. The MacBook is not design for someone that will be compiling programs, or using anything that starts with the names "Adobe" or "Autodesk". It's designed to be a great travel system - and it excels at that! I have the new rose gold with the M7 and it is quite speedy and is actually able to handle some Adobe (I haven't tried Autodesk on it yet). Personally, I love it.

    As a side note, I have EC on several systems and have not had an issue since the original Developer Beta.

  • MacBookSucks Says:

    This isn't just the worst computer I have ever bought, this is the worst product I have ever bought. Apple must know that El Capitan is not being properly handled by their computers. I have had this for five months and my Mail system has completely shut down (at this point works about 3% of the time), Safari is beyond sluggish and freezes over 90% (approximately) of my usage time, I have to reload Bluetooth objects several times a week (Apple specific Bluetooth devices). Repeated calls to Apple Support have been useless and have eaten up my time. This is affecting my ability to get work done and my ability to common irate on a professional and social level.

    My 2011 Macbook Pro is faster, more stable and does not suffer any of the problems that this computer does - and this is supposed to be newer and better. El Capitan is the worst OS I have ever used in Mac or PC. I am seeking a refund for my Macbook so I can start using my 2011 computer again. I will also be filing a consumer complaint with every relevant agency. If anyone is entering a class-action suit against Apple, please let me know.

  • KPOM01 Says:

    Does the reviewer get out into the real world? This MacBook is all over college campuses and for good reason. It is a great little notebook and a lot smaller and more portable even than "thinner" notebooks like the HP Spectre (which are much larger overall and have lower quality screens). The single port is not a problem when your data is on the cloud and you connect through wifi. The battery life is impressive and this machine is solid as a rock.

  • Matt Dorris Says:

    I love everything about this MacBook except the single port and the keyboard. I tried it in store and I may be able to get used to it if I were to buy it but a $1,299 laptop shouldn't offer such a poor typing experience.

  • Morten Rasmussen Says:

    There's also an m7 model clocked at 1.3 ghz! So three models in all. None of them have 16 gb ram, such a pity!!

  • JuanSoto Says:

    Man... that single port... it absolutely kills the Macbook. Everything else about it screams buy me. It's like Apple loves being the the object of ridicule. They need to step away from that bubble they live in and talk to real users.

  • Eric W Says:

    Very odd not to mention the HP Spectre which is thinner than the MacBook

    http://store.hp.com/us/en/ContentView?storeId=10151&eSpotName=hpspectre

Back to top