Skip to main content

Apple MacBook Pro (17-inch) Review

Our Verdict

You could get a faster Windows rig for the same price, but it wouldn't have the OSX bells and whistles of Apple's latest 17-inch notebook.

For

  • Elegant design
  • Relatively thin and light
  • Excellent bundled software
  • Good battery life

Against

  • Not the fastest performer
  • No high-def DVD option
  • Expensive

The Apple MacBook Pro proves that a desktop replacement notebook doesn't have to be a behemoth. Weighing just 6.8 pounds and measuring about an inch thick, this sleek system delivers a 17-inch widescreen and plenty of extras.

The simple brushed-aluminum shell of the MacBook Pro (compare prices) is as pleasing to the touch as it is to the eyes, and the clean look continues inside, with a monochromatic brushed-silver keyboard and deck. The keyboard is exceedingly comfortable and quiet, and we appreciate the oversized touchpad and single mouse button. One casualty of the minimalist aesthetic: The system lacks multimedia control keys, although you can use keyboard shortcuts to control these functions.

The 17-inch, 1680 x 1050-pixel widescreen (your choice of antiglare or glossy) is sharp and bright, with excellent color reproduction for image and video editors. It also has the best viewing-angle performance we've seen, which makes the MacBook Pro an ideal presentation tool. If you need a larger screen, the ATI Mobility Radeon X1600 graphics engine can drive an external display up to 2560 x 1600 pixels.

Hardware and software features abound. We love the backlit keyboard that illuminates automatically, thanks to the machine's light sensor. The built-in iSight camera and software enable four-way videoconferencing, and the included remote launches and controls Apple's Front Row interface for playing movies, music, and photos from across the room. You'll find FireWire 400 and 800 ports, and the ExpressCard slot accepts a Verizon Wireless EV-DO wireless broadband card. The newest MacBooks are equipped with the latest 802.11n technology.

Then there are the extras of the Mac OS X 10.4 itself, such as the handy Finder search utility and the Dashboard with dockable Widget applets. The included iLife suite makes it easy to manage and edit photos with iPhoto, manage and expand your music library with iTunes, make your own music with GarageBand, create movies and DVDs with iMovie and iDVD, create a Web site with iWeb, and more. Not enough? Load Apple's Boot Camp utility and set up the MacBook Pro as a dual-boot machine running either Mac OS X or Windows XP. In fact, the only software you're likely to need to add is an office suite.

Performance from the 2.33-GHz Intel Core 2 Duo CPU (married to 3GB of RAM in our test configuration) and ATI graphics was good but not class-leading. The machine scored 4,871 on PCMark05, and 4,996 on 3DMark03 while running Boot Camp (both acceptable, but on the lower end of the range here). Our F.E.A.R. test got a playable frame rate (39 fps) on its autodetect settings with a resolution of 1024 x 768. On the plus side, wireless throughput was excellent at 19.3 Mbps at 15 feet, and 14.6 Mbps at 50 feet. Battery life of 2 hours and 44 minutes was good for a 17-inch model and the best in the roundup.

For the price, you could certainly get a faster 17-inch Windows notebook, even one with a high-def DVD drive (which Apple doesn't yet offer). But it won't have all the Apple software and hardware extras, it'll weigh at least two pounds more, and it won't look nearly as good. We recommend opting for the standard 2GB of RAM instead of 3GB, which will bring the price down to $2,799.

Notebook owners: Do you have a great tech-support story? We want to hear all about the good, the bad, and the just plain stupid. Vent, give praise, or tell us how they couldn't help you at all. Our editors will feature the best stories in an upcoming issue of the magazine.

Suggested Stories:

Apple MacBook Pro (Core 2 Duo) Review

Apple's upgraded high-end notebook offers a faster processor and double the RAM, but how does that translate into real-world performance?

HP Pavilion dv9000z Review
Junk your old desktop and replace it with this big screen multimedia notebook.

Dual Core Notebooks Under $1,000

Everyone's abuzz about the power of dual-core processors and the slick new features of Windows Vista. And these six notebooks prove you can get both for less than a grand.

Tech Specs

RAM3GB
Size15.4x10.4x1
Weight6.8lbs
Display Size17
Native Resolution1680x1050
Hard Drive Size160GB
Ports (excluding USB)Microphone, Headphone, Firewire, Ethernet, DVI
Video Memory256MB
Wi-Fi802.11b/g
Warranty/SupportOne-year parts and labor/90-day toll-free 24/7
USB Ports3
Optical Drive Speed8X
Company Websitewww.apple.com
BrandApple
RAM Upgradable to3GB
Card SlotsExpressCard
Hard Drive Speed5,400rpm
Optical DriveDVDRW, DVD+R DL
BluetoothStereo Bluetooth
Graphics CardATI Mobility Radeon X1600
More