New MacBook Is Year's Biggest Tech Letdown So Far

  • MORE

If you haven't heard already, Apple announced an updated version of its 12-inch MacBook featuring a new 6th Gen Core M CPU, slightly better battery life and faster SSDs. And normally that would be a pretty decent refresh, except that Apple forgot to fix the real problems plaguing this system. That makes the latest MacBook one of the most disappointing new products so far in 2016.

macbook op ed lead 675403

The new MacBook's biggest problem is that it still has just one USB Type-C port. That means that without one of Apple's pricey dongles (or a third-party adapter), you'll often have to choose between recharging your system and plugging in any kind of peripheral that isn't a pair of headphones. There's no SD card reader (micro or otherwise), which means if you want to transfer pictures or videos so you can edit them on the MacBook's 12-inch Retina Display, you have to carry around an adapter with you at all times. Was it really too much for Apple to tack on a second USB port in the year since the first 12-inch MacBook was released?

MORE: Which MacBook Should You Buy? MacBook vs. Air vs. Pro

macbook adapters 675403

In fact, iPhone owners are forced to buy a $25 adapter if they want to connect their phones to this MacBook, since the Lightning cable that comes with every iPhone features a plug with an older USB Type-A connector. And Apple's USB-C dongle featuring HDMI, USB-A and USB-C ports costs an even pricier $79. That means you are practically required to purchase about $100 of adapters when you buy a new 12-inch Mac if you ever want to hook it up to any of your other devices. This brings me to my next point: the MacBook's price.

Starting at $1,299 for an 6th Gen Intel Core m3 CPU, 8GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD, the new 12-inch MacBook costs $400 more than an 11-inch MacBook Air, which has more ports, a faster Core i5 processor and arguably a more comfortable keyboard, albeit with half the RAM and a smaller, 128GB SSD. Measuring 0.68 inches thick with a weight of 2.38 pounds, the 11-inch MacBook Air isn't really that much bigger or heavier than the 0.52-inch thick, 2.03-pound MacBook either.

macbook oped one port 675403

Then there's the 13-inch MacBook Air, which features an Intel Core-i5 CPU and way better battery life, and now comes standard with 8GB of RAM, all for just $999. In our most recent review, the 13-inch MacBook Air boasted a battery life of 14 hours flat. Even if you take Apple's claim of an extra hour of battery life for the 12-inch MacBook at face value, and add that to the 8:43 mark we got from last year's machine, the new MacBook would still fall about 4 hours short of the 13-inch MBA's time.

macbook keyboard 675403

The 12-inch MacBook's biggest advantages are in its larger base storage and high-res screen. But if Apple ever bothered to update the Air line instead of letting it languish, those advantages probably wouldn't remain.

As it stands, the 12-inch MacBook seems like a laptop for people with more money than sense, and because Apple didn't feel like addressing the system's issues, I don't feel like this new model is much better than the 3.5-star version we reviewed last year. But maybe there will be a surprise beneath that shiny, new rose-gold finish.

 

Author Bio
Sam Rutherford
Sam Rutherford,
Sam is a former penguin trainer and archery instructor who dabbles in esports and has lived on three different continents. If you have some comments on new tech or the best noodle spots in NYC, drop a line @SamRutherford.
Sam Rutherford, on
Add a comment
6 comments
  • Henry 3 Dogg Says:

    "...that would be a pretty decent refresh, except that Apple forgot to fix the real problems plaguing this system ...The new MacBook's biggest problem is that it still has just one USB Type-C port."

    That may rule out it's use in Penguin training or archery instruction but for a programmer and system integrator that spends a lot of time on the road, it's great.

    It's incredibly small and light, with a decent sized quality keyboard.

    And that little USB-C socket with 4 high speed lanes is genius. A superset of SuperSpeed USB 3.1, it's more of a docking connector than just a USB port.

  • Ravi Sriram Says:

    As a long-time Mac(desktop)user,
    part of the reason I put off getting a MacBook is that the cost is just too prohibitive. But that's another issue.
    As I do graphics,cad work and illustration using a Wacom tablet I am leaning towards a convertible such as a ThinkPad
    Yoga or similar Windows device.
    In any event,my suggestion to Apple is to at least test out a 2-in-1 to address the needs of graphics people like myself, rather than just have disparate products like the iPad and the Macbook. Could be what they precisely need to revive their laptop line. Again, just something to consider. Thank you

  • Douglas Black Says:

    Finally, a reviewer with sense

  • Marquis Jones Says:

    Who pays $1300 for a "second computer". I'm not sure what planet you live on but the majority of people in this country can't afford an iMac AND a MacBook Pro AND this Macbook. Sorry but the prices on these products make it so many people aren't buying several. If you have a MacBook Pro I can't see why you'd pay $1300 for a less capable machine.

  • Zahid, Bangladesh Says:

    One Question will chase us definitely in near future - How many devices do we need practically to fulfill our demand? One man can use only one device at a time effectively- though he may open a second & third device keep running before him.

  • John Armwood Says:

    This review like the predecessor's review here is harsh rather narrow minded. This computer is not for you if you are kid who games but if you are an adult who has an iMac or 15 inch MacBook Pro this is an excellent second computer. A lot of people have two computers but Mr. Rutherford never thought of this possibility in his review. If you are a senior citizen who wants a light mobile computer with an excellent screen for your tired eyes. Again Mr. Rutherford did not consider this option. Some many reviewers narrowly look at devices from their own use perspective. They do not seem to understand how others might use this computer. I use a 15 inch MacBook Pro and a Chromebook Pixel LS. as my mobiler computer as well as a Samsung Galaxy Tab s 10.5 and Tab S 2 9.7. I rarely use my Surface Pro 3. Please be more open minded and flexible Mr. Rutherford.

Back to top